Protect and Survive

In 1980 the British government published a pamphlet called Protect and Survive, advising households on what to do in the event of nuclear attack. It told readers to build an inner refuge from doors and sandbags, to stockpile fourteen days of food and water, to whitewash their windows, and to label and bury the bodies of anyone who died in the shelter. The pamphlet had been prepared some years earlier for distribution only if war appeared imminent, and when its contents became public it was received with a mixture of horror and derision. Critics pointed out, correctly, that its advice would be close to useless against a large-scale attack. The pamphlet became a byword for bureaucratic absurdity, and inspired a small industry of satire.

Such documents repay rereading now, not to laugh at them, though some passages are hard not to laugh at, but because they are unusually clear examples of an institution trying to write for a catastrophe it cannot forecast. The thing I keep returning to in Protect and Survive, and in its American predecessors from the 1950s with their cartoon turtles and schoolchildren under desks, is the gap between the scale of the threat and the scale of the advice. The threat was civilisational. The advice was domestic. Doors off hinges; tins of food; a radio with spare batteries.

The standard reading is that this gap exposes the pamphlets as propaganda — as ways of making nuclear war seem survivable and therefore thinkable. There is something in that. But there is another reading, which I prefer. The domestic advice was absurd only for the worst case. For a range of lesser cases — a limited strike, fallout drifting from a distant target, a breakdown of supply chains, a period of chaos in which the state could not reach you for a fortnight — the advice about water, food, radios and sheltering would have mattered a great deal. The pamphlet failed as a guide to the end of the world. It was a fairly reasonable guide to the bad week before help arrived, and the error of its critics, and perhaps its authors, was to treat those as the same thing.

The same distinction runs through all serious thinking about AI preparedness. There are scenarios — some catastrophic misuse events, or a genuine loss of control over highly capable systems — against which household preparation is roughly as useful as whitewashed windows against a thermonuclear warhead. And there is a much larger set of scenarios, many of them considerably more likely, in which household preparation matters enormously: a lost job, a crashed pension, a drained bank account, a cloned voice on the phone to your father, a week in which the payment systems are down. A sane approach does not pretend the first set does not exist. Nor does it allow the vividness of the first set to distract from the mundane, tractable work of preparing for the second.

from Surviving the AI Apocalypse (2026)


Claude Opus 5.5:

Here’s a set of further-reading links for the excerpt, grouped to follow its argument.

The pamphlet itself

The public information films

The American predecessors

The critics and satirists

Historians of civil defence

‘The bad week before help arrives’: today’s equivalents

  • Prepare – GOV.UK: The UK government’s current household-preparedness site, covering flooding, fires and power cuts, with a downloadable household emergency plan. Read alongside Protect and Survive, it is the modest, ‘lesser cases’ version of the same advice.

  • EU Preparedness Union Strategy – European Commission: The March 2025 strategy, which encourages households to keep essential supplies for at least 72 hours: Protect and Survive’s fourteen days, scaled down.

AI preparedness: both sets of scenarios

  • International AI Safety Report 2026: The Bengio-led review by more than 100 AI experts, backed by over 30 countries and international organisations. It covers the catastrophic end, sorting risks into malicious use, malfunctions and systemic risks.

  • Gen-AI: Artificial Intelligence and the Future of Work – IMF: The ‘lost job’ scenario. It estimates that about 60 percent of jobs in advanced economies are exposed to AI.

  • Starling Bank Safe Phrases campaign: The ‘cloned voice on the phone to your father’ scenario. It reports that over a quarter of UK adults say they were targeted by an AI voice-cloning scam in the past year. Its recommended defence, a family safe phrase, is fittingly domestic.

  • Banks and payments hit by CrowdStrike outage – Finextra: The ‘week the payment systems are down’ scenario, in miniature. In July 2024 Waterstones, Waitrose and Wetherspoons were among retailers unable to take card payments after a single faulty software update.

Previous
Previous

On Testimony

Next
Next

The AI Effect